Not Your Average Bloody Mary: Your Guide To The 11 Most Unique Bloody Mary Mixes
When you are searching for a bloody mary mix to purchase in a saturated market, these 11 unique bloody mary mixes will stand out from the crowd and tantalize your tastebuds for a truly unique bloody mary mix!
Just say no…..when it comes to bland bloody marys! Not that there's anything wrong with a simple and classic bloody mary, or one that is dressed up with garnishes galore but that doesn’t mean your bloody mary needs to taste average by any stretch. It’s not only okay but fun and delicious to explore companies that put a twist on the traditional hangover cocktail. Impress your guests and liven up your brunch gathering with these 10 unique bloody mary mixes that are anything but average. Ranging from spicy, pickle infused, fermented, and even yellow, your tastebuds will thank you later!
Transparency: as always, this guide like any other posted on this blog is compiled by my own research and preferences. I’ve taste tested hundreds of bottled mixes over the years and although I may receive a small commission when you purchase some of these mixes that did not influence my decision to include them on this list!
Looking for gluten-free or vegan mixers? Check out those guides by yours truly HERE:
The 7 Best Gluten-Free Bloody Mary Mixes
The Best Vegan Bloody Mary Mixes on the Market
Madge’s Food Fermented Bloody Mary Mix
Yes you heard that correctly, fermented bloody mary mix. Founded by Mike and Jodi Miller, Madge’s Food Company set out with the goal to, “change the world one billion microbes at a time,” to not only make delicious and gut healthy fermented food and drinks but to help educate the world about the health benefits of eating and drinking such. Madge’s unique Fermented Bloody Mary Mix is one of a kind and the fermentation process allows for only a few key ingredients but an overdose of flavor. Sweet but savory, spicy, and great for your gut, don’t sleep on this mix. Try their spicy version for probably the hottest bloody mary I’ve ever had, but if flaming hot isn’t for you, stick with their “regular” mix.
Madge’s Fermented Bloody Mary Mix 2 pack
$13.00
Remedy any hangover with Bloody Point Mixing Co.’s unique bloody mary mix, the Remedy Mary. Combining the power of coffee and vitamins along with the hangover healing properties of bloody marys, Bloody Point’s Remedy Mary is infused with caffeine and vitamin B12. The coffee flavor is subtle and blends smoothly with the acidity and umami flavor of the tomato forward mix. Think “Bloody Mary energy drink” without all the extra fillers, chemicals, and sugar. Not only for hangovers this cocktail can boost your energy and prepare you for a day of weekend festivities or literally liven up any brunch gathering!
Bloody Point Mixing Co. Remedy Mary 32oz
$13.99
Gary’s Bloody Mary Mix
Gary’s Premium Cocktail mixers, including their Bloody Mary mix is a family owned and operated business. Garys sons who took over the company in 2016, wanted to carry on the vision of crafting quality and consistent mixers. What makes Gary’s Bloody Mary mix unique is the unique spices including real bitters and a subtle heat that is balanced by a flavorful brine. It may appear to be a traditional bloody mary mix from the outside, but when you sip Gary’s Bloody Mary Mix, it’s anything but!
Gary’s Bloody Mary Mix 32oz
$5.99
Natural Blonde Bloody Mary
Why go red when you can go Natural Blonde? After drinking some of the Gold Medal Drunken Tomato Award winning Natural Blonde’s Bloody Mary Mix you’ll be asking yourself the same question! Not your average bloody mary mix, this YELLOW bloody mary mix is made from locally sourced, hand-picked, golden yellow tomatoes. The yellow golden tomatoes and minimal ingredients give Natural Blonde a uniquely refreshing, light, sweet, and earthy flavor that won't fill you up like some of the highly processed mixers you can find on shelves. You and your guests will be drawn to it because of its vibrant color and will keep coming back for more because of the beautiful and delicate flavors.
Natural Blonde Bloody Mary 32oz
$14.00
Mary’s Mixers, Spicy Bloody Mary Mix
Turn Sunday scaries into Sunday Funday with gluten-free Mary’s Mixers Spicy Bloody Mary Mix. Mary’s Mixers are rich, tomato forward, and the perfect amount of spice and if you’re looking to take your heat to the next level, their spicy mix will be right up your alley. Owner Greg’s secret recipe only uses the finest ingredients in his mixes including organic horseradish and house-made pickle brine that cuts the heat and softens the powerful punch to your tastebuds. The unique thing about Marys Mixers Spicy mix is the slow and rustic burn of the mix that’ll heat up your day and jump start your metabolism. Mary’s Mixers also offers other cocktail mixers in addition to their The Drunken Tomato Awards Platinum-winning Classic Bloody Mary and CBD Mary Mixers. Get my CBD Breakfast Bloody Mary recipe HERE.
Marys Mixers Spicy Bloody Mary Mix 32oz
$12.99
Blood Brothers Premium Bloody Mary Mix
Blood Brothers Premium Bloody Mary Mix may look normal from the outside but it’s incredibly unique flavor is no wonder why it scored multiple Platinum Drunken Tomato Awards when the panel of expert judges sang its praises. Blood Brothers Premium Bloody Mary Mix is mixed with robust flavors like grapefruit juice that compliments the sweet and herbaceous flavors that come from the spices, in particular, Mexican oregano. Mexican oregano comes from the same family as lemon verbena giving it a citrus-forward but earthy and flavor that shines through in the mix. Contrast that with a pinch of clam broth to balance out the multidimensional mix and you’ve got yourself one tasty, but unique bloody mary.
Blood Brothers Premium Bloody Mary Mix 3 Pack
$26.95
Pittsburgh Pickle Co. Briney Mary
Another Platinum Drunken Tomato Awards winner, Briney Mary is not your average, pickle mary. Yes there are a lot of bloody mary mixes out there that have pickle juice or brine in them because, well….it’s delicious but Pittsburgh Pickle Co’s established family recipe is a step above the rest. Each Briney Mary bottle is made with fresh ingredients including horseradish and Pittsburgh Pickle Co.’s signature brine. The combination of Pittsburgh Pickle Co.’s signature brine and their zesty, flavorful, hair of the dog bloody mary will have you getting your bloody mary brine on! Brine on: verb; doing the happy dance when the brine hits your tastebuds. Not only delish, this unique pickle brine bloody mary mix will send hangovers floating away down the Allegheny, Monongahela and Ohio Rivers, read more about it HERE.
Pittsburgh Pickle Co. Briney Mary Bloody Mary Mix 32oz
$14.99
Sportsman’s Redneck Juice, Clam Diggers
Born out of founder Ed Fazekas bar in Somerset, WI, Sportsman’s Redneck Juice, Clam Diggers mix is the perfect companion to any outdoor activity because the spicy and savory mix leaves you feeling warm and fuzzy on the inside with a happy belly. Now rebranded as Caesars Bloody Mary Mix, the bold and delicious flavor combined with the convenient jug it comes in, lends itself to taking it outdoors. Sportsman’s Caesar Mix is truly unique, even from a traditional Caesar cocktail because it combines their award winning Sportsman's Redneck Juice with just a splash of clam juice. If you’re on the fence about Caesar’s this unique bloody mary mix is the perfect way to dip your toes into the Caesar cocktail pond! Check out this Cozy Picnic Bloody Mary Recipe I created using Sportsman's HERE!
Sportsman’s Redneck Juice Caesar Mix 64oz Jug
$20.00
If you’re curious what the difference between a bloody mary and a caesar is, check out my blog HERE.
Crispy Pig Whiskey Bloody Mary
Are you Ready To Drink some unique bloody marys, literally and figuratively? Then crack open a can of Crispy Pig’s ready to drink, Whiskey Bloody Mary. Not only is it blended with whiskey instead of vodka but it comes already mixed in a can so you can drink it on the go and take it with you everywhere! Now you may seem skeptical at first, especially if you don’t like whiskey but in the Drunken Tomato Awards blind tasting the judges awarded this ready to. drink whiskey bloody mary mix a Platinum medal in the unique category because it’s freaking good! Made with fresh quality tomatoes, savory spice, a hint of sweet maple, smoky whiskey and a dash of heat. Plus this unique bloody mary mix pairs perfectly with food! Read more about Crispy Pig and the convenience of ready to drink on my blog HERE.
Crispy Pig Whiskey Bloody Mary 8 pack of 12oz cans
$29.99
Savor & Salt Bloody Mary Mix
Savor every sip of multiple Drunken Tomato Award medal winner, Savor & Salt’s vegan bloody mary mix. Savor and Salt’s original mix is inspired by the flavors of the Chicago hot dog. The flavors of this unique bloody mary mixer; savory and umami, briney, a little bit salty, and smoky notes lend to the taste of a delicious grilled dog. With every sip, you’ll feel like you’re in Chicago chowing on their famous hot dogs, for a unique experience that transports you to the Windy City!! In addition to all of their bloody mary mixers being vegan, gluten-free, and all-natural, Savor & Salt offers 5 tantalizing rim salts for all your bloody mary needs!
Savor & Salt Classic Bloody Mary Mix 32oz
$8.00
Get Savor & Salt
Toma Bloody Mary Horseradish
Elevate your brunch game with gluten-free and vegan Toma Horseradish Bloody Mary. A unique recipe that uses fresh and creative ingredients like tomatillo sauce and owner Alex’s homemade sriracha recipe, the mix beats to its own drum while still balancing the classic flavor of a bloody mary. Toma’s horseradish mix adds vigor without overpowering the cocktail and pairs well with seafood & charcuterie, and can be mixed with any liquor of your choice for a bright, citrus-forward, and hair-of-the-dog cocktail. The distinct flavor and aromatics will lift your senses and your spirits for an elevated brunch cocktail! Get my Cucumber Gin Bloody Mary garnished with oysters or Pisto Manchego (yes you can cook with Toma too!) recipes made with Toma Bloody Mary Mixers HERE & HERE.
Toma Bloody Mary Mixer 32oz 2 pack
$25.98
Get 15% off Toma Bloody Mary w/this link and code BMObsessed15